Hi everybody, I hope this blog post finds you all well. I'm doing better my second week back in NYC, about to head down to DC for the holiday weekend and spend some time in the old Rosenbloom homestead.
Still, I wanted to put up a quick post before I traveled, and this article by Larry Ferlazzo for Educational Leadership, the flagship publication of the Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development caught my eye. Check it out!
Eight Things Skilled Teachers Think, Say, and Do
Among the many challenges teachers face, often the most difficult is
how to engage students who seem unreachable, who resist learning
activities, or who disrupt them for others. This is also one of the
challenges that skilled teachers have some control over. In my nine
years of teaching high school, I've found that one of the best
approaches to engaging challenging students is to develop their
The root of intrinsic is the Latin intrinsecus, a combination of two words meaning within and alongside. It's likely that our students are
intrinsically motivated—just motivated to follow their own interests,
not to do what we want them to do. Teachers' challenge is to work
alongside our students, to know their interests and goals, and to
develop trusting relationships that help students connect their learning
to their goals in a way that motivates from within.
How can teachers do this? It's helpful to consider this question in
three parts: What skilled teachers think, what they say, and what they
What Skilled Teachers Can Think
What we think guides how we view the world, including how we view
challenging students. Developing and maintaining three mind-sets will
help teachers maintain their equilibrium in the face of behavior or
resistance to learning from certain students that would ordinarily knock
us off balance.
1. Remember that authoritative beats authoritarian.
Being authoritarian means wielding power unilaterally to control
someone, demanding obedience without giving any explanation for why
one's orders are important. Being authoritative, on the other hand,
means demonstrating control, but doing so relationally through listening
and explaining. Studies of effective parenting have found that children
view parents who use an authoritative style as legitimate authority
figures; such children are less likely to engage in delinquent behavior. The opposite is true for children of authoritarian parents (University
of New Hampshire, 2012).
2. Believe that everyone can grow.
Many teachers are familiar with Carol Dweck's distinction between a
"growth" mind-set and a "fixed" one. When we have a growth mind-set, we
believe that everyone has the inner power to grow and change. We see
mistakes as opportunities to learn. Holding a fixed mind-set leads us to
believe that people's traits—such as intelligence—are immutable. A
mistake on the part of someone we believe is unintelligent seems to
validate that belief.
Teachers aren't superhuman. There are some things we cannot
accomplish. But we must ask ourselves whether we too readily write off
students who try our patience as "incapable," or some similar adjective,
without considering whether differentiating instruction for these
students might spur change and growth.
3. Understand that power isn't a finite pie.
I was a community organizer for 19 years before I became a teacher. A
key lesson I learned was that power isn't a finite pie. If I share the
power I have, that doesn't mean I'll have less. In fact, the pie will
get bigger as more possibilities are created for everyone.
Power struggles are at the root of much misbehavior. William Glasser
(1988) believes that students have a basic need for power and that 95
percent of classroom management issues occur as a result of students
trying to fulfill this need. Having more power actually helps students
learn. Giving students choices—about their homework, assignments, how
they're grouped, and so on—leads to higher levels of student engagement
and achievement (Sparks, 2010).
What Skilled Teachers Can Say
4. Give positive messages.
Positive messages are essential to motivation. Subtle shifts in
teacher language infuse positive messages throughout our interactions. Here are three practices I've found helpful.
Use positive framing. "Loss framed" messages (if you do this,
then something bad will happen to you) don't have the persuasive
advantage that they're often thought to have. "Positive framed messages"
(if you do this, these good things will happen) are more effective
(Dean, 2010). Positive messages that
connect students' current actions to broader student-identified hopes or
goals are different from "if-then" statements focused on what teachers
want students to do ("If you don't get out of your seat without
permission, then you'll get extra credit"). As Daniel Pink (2009) notes,
such extrinsic manipulations don't develop students' higher-order
thinking skills or long-term commitments to change.
Say "yes." Avoidant instruction is language that emphasizes
what people should not do ("Don't walk on the grass." "Don't chew gum"). Some researchers (British Psychological Society, 2010) believe that a
more effective way to get a desired behavior is to emphasize what you
want people to do. For example, if a student asks to go the restroom,
but the timing isn't right, rather than saying no, I try to say, "Yes,
you can. I just need you to wait a few minutes." Or if a student is
talking at an inappropriate time, instead of saying, "Don't talk!" I
sometimes go over and tell that learner, "I see you have a lot of energy
today. We'll be breaking into small groups later and you'll have plenty
of time to talk then. I'd appreciate your listening now."
Say "please" and "thank you." People are more likely to comply
with a task (and do so more quickly) if someone asks them instead of
tells them (Yong, 2010). I've found that "Can you please sit down?" is
more effective than "Sit down!" Saying thank you provides immediate
positive reinforcement to students. Research (Sutton, 2010) shows that
people who are thanked by authority figures are more likely to
cooperate, feel valued, and exhibit self-confidence.
Teachers are human, and we make plenty of mistakes. There is no reason why we shouldn't apologize when we do.
But saying, "I'm sorry," may not be enough. I often use the "regret,
reason, and remedy" formula recommended by Dorothy Armstrong (2009). For
example, one afternoon my students Omar and Quang were paired up in my
class but were sitting passively while everyone else focused on the task
at hand. I said sharply, "Come on now, get working!" A few minutes
later, I said simply to the two boys, "I'm sorry I barked at you
earlier. I was frustrated that you weren't doing what I'd asked you to
do. I'll try to show more patience in the future." They clearly focused
more energy on their work after this apology.
What Skilled Teachers Can Do
6. Be flexible.
Being flexible might be the most important thing teachers can "do" to
help students who challenge us—in fact all students—to get past
whatever challenges of their own they confront. Three practices help me
differentiate instruction and classroom management in a way that helps
Help them get started. Psychologist Bluma Zeigarnik identified
the Zeigarnik Effect: Once people start doing something, they tend to
want to finish it (Dean, 2011). If we get a disengaged or anxious
student started, that's half the battle. For a task that's likely to
challenge some students, present a variety of ways to get started: a
menu of questions, the option to create a visual representation of a
concept, a chance to work with a partner. Encourage students to launch
themselves by just answering the first question or the easiest one.
Help postpone tempting distractions. Making a conscious
decision to postpone giving in to temptation can reduce a desire that's
getting in the way of a goal (Society for Personality and Social
Psychology, 2012). My student Mai was frequently using her cell phone to
text message during class. I didn't want to take her phone away, so I
made a deal with her—she could text in my classroom during two specific
times: from the moment she entered the room until the bell rang and as
soon as the lunch bell rang. Since we made that deal, Mai hardly ever
uses her cell phone during class. Even more significant, she hardly ever
uses it during our agreed-on times.
Acknowledge stress. As most of us know from experience, people
tend to have less self-control when they're under stress (Szalavitz,
2012). When a student is demonstrating self-control issues in my class, I
often learn through a conversation with him or her that this student is
going through family disruptions or similar problems. Sometimes, just
providing students an opportunity to vent worries can have a positive
7. Set the right climate.
Pink (2009) and other researchers have found that extrinsic rewards
work in the short term for mechanical tasks that don't require much
higher-order thinking, but they don't produce true motivation for work
that requires higher-order thinking and creativity. However, everyone
needs "baseline rewards"—conditions that provide adequate compensation
for one's presence and effort.
At school, baseline rewards might include fair grading, a caring
teacher, engaging lessons, and a clean classroom. If such needs aren't
met, Pink (2009) notes, the student will focus on "the unfairness of her
situation and the anxiety of her circumstance. You'll get neither the
predictability of extrinsic motivation nor the weirdness of intrinsic
motivation. You'll get very little motivation at all" (p. 35).
8. Teach life lessons.
My colleagues and I frontload our school year with what we call life-skills lessons. These simple, engaging activities help students see how it's in their short-term and long-term interest to try their best.
For example, a lesson might highlight how the learning process
physically alters the brain. This particular lesson encourages a growth
mind-set. It was eye-opening to one of my students who had claimed,
"We're all born smart or dumb and stay that way." In terms of keeping up
kids' motivation, the times throughout the year when I refer back to
these concepts and reflect on how they apply to learning struggles are
as important as the initial lessons.
What We Can Always Do
Consistently implementing these practices is easier said than
done—and is probably impossible unless you're Mother Teresa. But most
teachers already do something that makes all these practices flow more
naturally, and that we can do more intensely with conscious effort—we
build relationships with students. Caring relationships with teachers
helps students build resilience. By fostering these relationships, we
learn about students' interests and goals, which are fuel for