Sunday, March 12, 2017

Follow the Leader

This past week, we underwent some drama with the teachers and their lack of motivation.  I would have been at my wit's end (done under also by a bout of amoebic dysentery - NOT pretty) except that wee Kaitlin was here to help.

And help she did.  Our tiny taskmaster took charge like a boss and whereas my kvetching at our, primarily well-meaning and generally effective, teaching staff, fell on deaf ears, her exercises in leadership intervention and our new catchphrase of "team-building through communication and trust" turned a mini mutiny into calm seas.
 
After all, we cannot help the kids we are meant to if our team is broken and the teachers are not invested.  How then, to get them invested and to recognize that working for Toa is not about making this mzungu happy, but rather about creating a professional persona for each of these young ladies where one did not exist before.

It's a new thought for sure, and perhaps I took for granted that they saw it all along.  It may have been just about a paycheck for them in the past, which is totally fine, but I wanted them to see that by showing up late or leaving early, not coming at all or coming and then not being active, the person they are letting down is not ME.

Rather, walimu wetu, it is your students who are counting on learning their lessons, it is your colleagues with whom you share the workload, and it is you yourself, who deserves, and can achieve, more than a paltry monthly stipend and the confines of a rural shamba.

In the spirit of this past week's International Women's Day, let's be bold, let's be the change!

In the videos and diagram below, we all tried an exercise to figure out what kinds of leaders we are: flexible, people-pleaser types; opinionated stand-takers; unemotional analysts; or impassioned forces of nature.  Check it out!!




Friday, March 3, 2017

"Word."


A versatile declaration, originating (more or less) in hip-hop culture.

Has no single meaning, but is used to convey a casual sense of affirmation, acknowledgement, agreement. 

Check out this recent editorial from The Citizen. 

####

Tanzania Needs More Teachers Now Than Ever Before


With the introduction of the free education policy by the fifth phase government, by March there were 8,340,128 children in public primary schools across the country.  We saw desk-making campaigns in a bid to ensure we don't have scenes of children learning seated on dusty floors. 

To teach the over 8 million children, there were 191,604 teachers, which gave a teacher-pupil ratio of 1:41.  The distribution of teachers is far from even, as it has been found that at some schools, the ratio was one teacher for every three learners at two schools in Tabora Region and one in Tanga.  The worst scenario was at a school in Kigoma Region that had one teacher handling 727 pupils! 

According to the Tanzania Teachers Union, public secondary schools have a shortage of 40,000 teachers.  At least 30,000 of the "missing" teachers are for science subjects.  This situation notwithstanding, the government has plans to employ only a tenth of the required number this year. 

Apart from budgetary constraints, people expect to be told why we have a big teaching staff shortage when there are so many qualified teachers who are waiting to be employed.  Right from lower primary school, the playing ground for education is uneven.  Much as we need more teachers, the distribution has to be streamlined, for quality education is a right for every Tanzanian child. 

Incentives have to be offered to teachers, monetary and non-monetary, especially those posted to remote areas.  Working conditions and accommodation have to be tackled urgently. 

Local government leaders need to promote community participation especially in rural schools.  Many teachers are forced to find additional income to augment their meager earnings, which invariably has a serious negative impact on their overall performance. 

The government needs acknowledge that it is only through a well-developed education system that the country will realize its dream of becoming a middle-income economy by 2025.

Thursday, March 2, 2017

Postcards From the Edge

Well, hel-lo there!  Sorry for the long silence, things have been cah-razy busy in the hizzy, and I've not had time to write!!

Carla is "out of Africa," as they say, and safely back in the United States, so this piece is an ode to her time here.  While we are certainly a madcap mother-daughter team, we are nowhere near the level of dysfunction Shirley MacLaine and Meryl Streep portrayed in the film based on Carrie Fisher's life, but still, I thought it was an apropos title for this post since there were definitely many times we felt on "the edge" of something or other....

As she has done in past years, Carla came for a little over a month, mostly to help with Toa Nafasi administrative matters and to generally crack the whip and make sure all of us are doing our jobs.  (Note: Some of us are not.  And Carla is not happy.)

As a seminal member of the U.S. Board of Directors, my mom takes an active role in the scaffolding that keeps Toa propped up.  Her support is HUGELY (bigly?) helpful to me as when she is here, especially at the start of the school year, I can entrust certain tasks to her (accounting, copyediting, logistics) while I can be in school doing intake, observation, and testing.  The relationship is ideal as it keeps both of us busy but not so busy that we are anywhere close to "the edge." 

Anyhoo, this year Carlita touched down in Kilimanjaro with her usual aplomb and we got to work.  Since I had arrived just six weeks or so before her, and experienced the theft of some stuff from one of my suitcases which had ostensibly been searched by TSA (TSA or KIA, I wonder?!), she came correct and left little notes to would-be robbers in her suitcases.  Of course, she rolled through twenty-four hours of international travel, customs and passport control completely unscathed.  She's Carla, after all.


Our first couple of weeks were relatively peaceful as we made the rounds to the bank, accountant and auditor, each school for salaams, and dinners out with my friends.  At 72, Carla is spry but jetlag, red wine, and keeping Drogo out of her room did her in at night.


We managed to visit the schools several times over the course of her month here, some visits positive (greeting the headmasters and teachers and seeing our Toa staff at each site), some negative (the construction of the tent at Mnazi is still nowhere near complete and the excuses are off the charts: the soil needs to be watered before the concrete can be laid?  O-kay.)

Carla particularly enjoyed meeting the new headmaster at Msandaka, one Mr. Mlinga.  I would not be lying if I said that there was nearly a love affair between the two, culminating in a rather intimate scene that both Kaitlin (Toa's new volunteer) and I were unfortunately witness to.

Carla loved herself some Mlinga as he did not ask us for anything above and beyond what the Project was already providing, and in fact, he vociferously thanked us for the work we were doing here in Tanzania and our dedication to the children at his school.  This is a rare thing for us.  A rare and beautiful thing.


On another visit to Msandaka, Kaitlin and I found out that Mr. Mlinga speaks French!  Mais, oui!!  Knowing that ma petite maman would get a kick out of this (she was raised in Geneva), I promised Mr. Mlinga that I would return with his amour before she left so they could converse en francais.

Fast-forward the intimate scene a deux that I can't erase from my mind and see Mlinga's ode to Carla penned below and delivered by Kaitlin whose glee in doing so was about on par with Drogo's when I open a fresh can of tuna.

PLEASE, do not think he means ME when he writes "Dear Sarah."  Oh no, he DEFINITELY means Carla, but I'm not quite sure who then he thinks I am....  Oh well, tant pis.  (Note the heart and the message, tu es ma lumiere, which they called each other in the meeting of intimacy, "you are my light.")


Unfortunately for Mlinga, Carla was quite the little minx on this trip and he was not her only BF.  She also got on quite nicely with Mr. Liana, the District Education Officer for Moshi Municipal and a man we REALLY need to have on our side.

Theirs was a different sort of love affair, however.  Less gentle and lumiere-y.  I think it was a case of two strong-willed personalities meeting, discussing, and coming to a mutual respect for each other.  Certainly Liana shall not be forgetting Carla Peterson anytime soon.  Here they are discussing pit latrines, of all things.


But wait, there's more.  After meeting with Liana at the Municipal Council, we toddled on up the stairs (Carla's idea) to seek out the mayor of Moshi who happens to also be my neighbor.  Whoa.  WHOA.  WHOA.  More love.  BIG love.

I have lived across the street from Ray Mboya since 2013 and never met the man.  I always felt safe knowing he was there and appreciated the proximity in that way, but I never really considered that he might be useful to the Project.  Or at least that he might open some doors for us.  Well, I think Carla accomplished that task with our meeting with the Honorable Lord Mayor, who is about my age and might want to date me (jury's still out on that one).  He was certainly taken with her, and you know what they say: like mother like daughter.  He did mention that we were conducting "public" business in his office but since we are neighbors, we can meet on "private" matters at home.  Hmm....

Last but not least, there is Mr. Makenga, the headmaster at Kiboriloni who is also brand-new and who was also tickled pink by my dear mama.  No clue why as they met for all of five seconds, but he was so enthralled that he asked her to come back so that he could bestow her with a "surprise."

We met him just a couple days before Mom was due to depart so our meeting was really meant to be a hello/goodbye collabo but Makenga was having none of it and tracked us down the very day that Carla left so she could receive her surprise.  Check the video that Kaitlin took of the great unveil below.
 

All in all, it was a lovely visit and we miss her dearly here in Moshi.  Me, Kaitlin, and Drogo are making do, but really it is not the same without her.  And I think all her "boyfriends" here would agree!  Ah well, farewell dear Carla, until next year!!

Tuesday, February 14, 2017

My NEW Valentine (Not My Blue Valentine)

No half-forgotten dreams nor pebbles in my shoes (that's for all you Tom Waits fans out there), this post is an homage to the holiday of St. Valentine's, a day for lovers to celebrate love in all its many splendored glory.

Of course, there are many kinds of love: romantic love, platonic love, familial love, the love of a mother for her child, the love of a student for her teacher, the love between two toddlers on a swingset or two teenagers at sleepaway camp, cat love, dog love, God love, gay love, starcrossed love, unrequited love, unrelenting love, the love of a preacher/rabbi/imam for his church/shul/mosque, overwhelming love, overreaching love, love against the odds, love is all we need, Mariah Carey's Vision of Love and Bob Marley's One Love, erotic love, free love, love at first sight, and (take it or leave it) polyamorous love.

Since I'm already feeling all loved up at home with my mama (Carla) love and my paka (Drogo) love, this post is about my newest love, a little girl named Sadia who stole my heart this past week while I was observing the teachers assess the 2016 cohorts for the third and final time.

Because Angi had been concerned about the normative quality of the testing last year as well as the data entry, I tried to take appropriate measures to cut down where mistakes could be made.  Thus, rather than pay full attention to how the kids were testing or helping to test them myself, I set myself the task of carefully watching each Toa teacher as she assessed each child to make sure they were following protocol.

Since this is ultimate test for the 2016 kids, I deemed it a good opportunity for our teachers to get their practice on, in preparation for the 2017 group who we will start assessing in about a week or so.  Since that will be MAYHEM (no love lost for that task there), I figured why not make sure we are all in fighting shape before getting back into the ring....?

In this short clip from observing Teacher Glory with Sadia, I experienced a very sweet love.  A heartwarming love for Glory whose kind nature shown through as she tested the blushing and beautiful Sadia.  And a tender and maternal love for Sadia herself, for having come so far from her first assessment and for allowing herself to relax and smile and have fun now completing her third.  Even though she shakes her head at Glory's tease, "You're happy, huh?" it's clear she is.  And really, who doesn't love a happy kid?  (Probably a lot of jackholes in Congress right now, but take the phrase as rhetorical before the warm fuzzies wear off....)

So from our hearts to yours, Team Toa wishes everyone a happy Valentine's Day and reminds you that, as bleak as the world may seem just now, love actually is all around.  (Thank you, Hugh Grant.)

Sunday, February 12, 2017

Joyce to the World

Hey everybody, hope all are well.  Busy, busy, busy here in the Mosh with Carla here on her annual "40 days and 40 nights" trip to Tanz plus my Aunty Jane and her friend Marie-Louise who, after a week of Moshi mishemishe'ing (going here and there), will soon leave us for the wonders of Serengeti followed by Zanzibar.

Also, we have a new volunteer in the hizzy: Kaitlin Marrs, a nineteen-year-old American missy on a gap semester has blessed The Toa Nafasi Project with her youth and enthusiasm.  Just in time as far as I'm concerned; this year has me feeling more aged and fatigued than ever before.

More on Kaitlin later, while for now I leave you with this article I found from The Citizen earlier this year.

Do you remember my blog post last year round this time titled "Dear Joyce" (http://toanafasi.blogspot.com/2016/01/dear-joyce.html)?  It was an open letter from the media writer at The Daily News, pleading with the newly appointed Education Minister under Magufuli, Joyce Ndalichako, to do her due diligence in her new post.

A year later, and Mama Joyce has lots to show for her time in office - the good, the bad, and the ugly - as you will read below.  I thought it was a timely piece to reprint now as our own newly minted Education Secretary in the United States is making also making headlines.

Never a dull moment in politics - this much I know is true!

####

Tanzania: Ndalichako's Popular, Controversial Orders

There were hopes that things would change for the better in the education sector when President John Magufuli appointed Professor Joyce Ndalichako as the Minister of Education, Science, Technology, and Vocational Training.

 
Stakeholders were optimistic that her appointment would bring positive change in the sector that over the years has been facing numerous challenges, particularly in the quality of education and addressing teachers' woes.

As the year 2016 wound up, a lot has happened in Professor Ndalichako's docket, some of which she has been praised for and some she has been criticized for by education stakeholders and experts. 

Her statements and decisions in the last twelve months have been a source of hot and endless debates. 

GPA System Ditched 

On January 20th while in Dodoma, Professor Ndalichako announced that Tanzania would stop using the grade point average (GPA) system to grade candidates in national Form Four and Six examinations.  She directed the National Examinations Council of Tanzania (NECTA) to immediately revert to the division system, which was abolished in 2014.

Her decision to restore the old system was made after NECTA had failed to convince her on the advantages of the GPA system over the division system they previously used. 

Professor Ndalichako said that NECTA had switched following recommendations by stakeholders.  "However, we are not told who these stakeholders were: how many were they, where did they meet, and what exactly did they suggest.  It shows that this is just an excuse."

"Yes, we need change, but change should be informed and backed by scientific grounds.  If change doesn't conform to these tenets, then it is undesirable," Professor Ndalichako said.

The decision to introduce the GPA grading system almost cost NECTA Executive Director, Dr. Charles Msonde, his job, two weeks before the Minister decided to ditch it.

Professor Ndalichako's decision to stop the use of GPA in grading was well-received by education stakeholders and experts, who said the system was unjustifiable and would affect efforts being made to achieve the goal of quality education. 

700 UDOM Students Expelled 

In May, Professor Ndalichako announced the expulsion of 782 students who were pursuing a special diploma in science education at the University of Dodoma.

The move followed reports that lecturers instructing them in their program had boycotted after the government had disagreed with them regarding their remuneration.

The Minister's decision raised public concern over the fate of the students who were given 72 hours to leave the campus premises.

Members of Parliament, lecturers, and education experts expressed grave concern on the way the Minister had handled the matter.

A few weeks later, fresh details emerged on the true cause of the expulsion of the students when President John Magufuli addressed the University of Dar es Salaam (UDSM) community on June 3rd. 

He told the gathering that preliminary findings showed that the majority of UDOM students who were admitted to pursue a special Diploma in Science (Education) lacked pre-entry qualifications, with some them achieving as low as Division Four in their national Form Four results.

On July 20th, Professor Ndalichako called back to the university only 382 students of the 782 initially enrolled, saying the vetting exercise had established that they were the only ones qualified for admission to the special diploma courses.

But the Minister had later reallocated the students to various teaching colleges in Morogoro, Butimba, Mpwapwa, Songea, and Tukuyu to pursue primary school teaching courses.  And those who were in their second year were reallocated to Kasulu and Korogwe to complete their studies. 

Student Battering 

On October 10th, Professor Ndalichako ordered the expulsion of three trainee teachers after they were seen battering an Mbeya secondary school student in footage that went viral on social media.

In addition to that, the school's head teacher was also demoted as directed by the Minister in the President's Office (Regional Administration and Local Authorities), Mr. George Simbachawene.

The video shows three trainee teachers from the University of Dar es Salaam beating up a student at Mbeya Day Secondary School.

Professor Ndalichako described the incident that occurred September 28th, as unethical, cruel, and criminal, adding that the trainee teachers had lost their opportunity to complete their studies.

The decision was however taken by some education stakeholders as an overreaction of the responsible ministers. 

Order on Graduation Gowns 

Professor Ndalichako banned the wearing of graduation gown on levels below the first degree "to encourage those in lower levels to desire to reach the top levels."  This statement was released on November 10th.

She said it was undesirable for the gowns to be worn by children in nursery schools, which defeated the whole purpose of making it unique for the degree level.

She said that as the government tries to improve the quality of education matching the growth of science and technology, it was important to differentiate different levels of education so that to motivate the lower level students to climb even higher in the education ladder.

Various education stakeholders hailed Professor Ndalichako's decision, pointing out that it had reached a point where people took the graduation gown as a parting dress. 

Ban on Textbooks 

On December 2nd, Prime Minister Kassim Majaliwa banned private companies from publishing textbooks as one of the measures to ensure provision of quality education in the country.

Instead, he instructed the Tanzania Education Authority (TEA) to supervise the publishing of all textbooks used in schools in the country.

He said that apart from ensuring quality education, the government also aims to enable each student to use his or her own book in the classroom.

Mr. Majaliwa said different firms have been publishing textbooks without adhering to given standards and that there have been many complaints due to poor quality and many mistakes.

The decision drew various reactions from education stakeholders, with some expressing disappointment, arguing that the decision would further sink the country's education sector.

Sunday, January 29, 2017

Take That, Jeff Sessions!

In an almost perfect coda to last week's entry, I am posting the latest graphs formulated by the inimitable Angi Stone-MacDonald showing the results of last year's cohort in their first six months of intervention.  

Since then, of course, they've undergone another six months of intervention and will need to be tested for the third and final time, but we've not yet started this process.  

Schools just opened up again for 2017 on the 9th of January and predictably, everything is going very polepole.  This is not a surprise.  It happens every year.  After a month off for vacation (Christmas and New Year's festivities galore), the shock of re-entering real life (and work) is quite the doozy.  I guess this is true everywhere but perhaps doubly so in a climate where our winter months are actually the hottest time of the year.  It's quite difficult to get into the whole hapa kazi tu mode when all you want to do is drink cold beers under the shade of a palm tree.  And sleep.
 
Anyhoo, someone PLEASE tell Jeff Sessions that special education is NOT an indication of the "decline of civility" as he suggests, but rather a way of ensuring that ALL children receive the education they deserve and that is appropriate for their abilities.  

Though, I'm guessing that if he doesn't care about SPED in an American context, he's probably not gonna be swayed by the successes of my little Tanzanian program....  Make America Great Again?  Yeah, right....

PS: You can see that the third child on the second graph, "AH," did not make any progress from Test 1 to Test 2, and we know exactly who he is and have a plan in place to board him at Gabriella.  So despite his lack of progress with Toa, he will be just fine once he's settled in his new classes.  I'm guessing Mr. Sessions would find this VERY perturbing and shockingly inconvenient!
 
 

Monday, January 23, 2017

Sessions: "He Clearly Doesn't Know a Whole Lot of Anything"

I wrote this entry before leaving the States but never found an appropriate time to post.  Why not now, a few days after the inauguration of our new President?  Might as well start getting used to the status quo....

#### 

Hi all, it has been just about one month since Donald Trump was elected to be the 45th President of the United States in a surprising and disturbing upset over Hillary Clinton.  As was true during his loooong and tiresoooome campaign, The Donald continues to delight in shocking the public with his brazen political viewpoints, bizarre social media habits, and now, his totally inappropriate choices for his cabinet members.

The hearts of Democrats everywhere are bleeding over the likes of Rex Tillerson, Exxon CEO and Putin pal, as Secretary of State; James Mattis, former "Mad Dog" Marine general, as Secretary of Defense; Betsy DeVos, GOP megadonor and public school naysayer, as Secretary of Education; Ben Carson, former Trump foe and self-pronounced government novice, as Secretary of Housing and Urban Development; and Scott Pruitt, well-known climate change skeptic who brought twelve lawsuits against the EPA, as head of the same agency.  Dark times are indeed upon us.

Perhaps the scariest pick of all - for me, for Toa, for special needs and learning-disabled children in America, for similarly challenged children all over the world who look to their American counterparts as shining examples of how to succeed in the face of such disabilities and needs - is Jeff Sessions.  

One of Trump's earliest supporters during the campaign, the anti-immigration senator from Alabama has a much criticized record on race relations and was once denied a judgeship amid concerns over past comments about blacks.  As Attorney General, Sessions will head the Department of Justice.

Please see below a recent article in Forbes expressing a variety of concerns raised over Sessions' appointment as pertains to special education and disability rights.  (BTW, the Sessions outrage poured out of multiple sources the last couple weeks, so in addition to Forbes, if you're interested to know more about this vile creature, check out The Parent Herald, The Washington Post, and The Huffington Post, to name a few.  I feel sure Sesh can also be found amidst the pages of The Satanic Verses, Goethe's Faust, several volumes of the Harry Potter series, and any book by George Orwell, fiction or nonfiction.)

####

Would Special Education Rights Be Safe With Jeff Sessions As U.S. Attorney General? 


Senator Jeff Sessions, if confirmed as U.S. Attorney General in the incoming Trump administration, would become the nation's top law enforcement officer.  That would make him responsible for defending and enforcing federal education laws that guarantee students with disabilities the "free appropriate public education" (FAPE) they are legally due.

But special education and disability advocates worry that he may not be up to task given the attitudes and misconceptions he revealed in statements to the Senate floor in 2000.

"Sessions perpetuates the common misconception that inclusion means throwing all students together in the same classroom, with the same curriculum and with the same supports," said Shannon Des Roches Rosa, senior editor at Thinking Person’s Guide to Autism and mother to an autistic adolescent.  "What inclusion actually means is that students are part of the same school community, with the curriculum differentiated for individualized learning styles (which may mean that students don't all have the same classes together), and supports in place for those who need them.  Research consistently demonstrates that students included in this way thrive—all the students, not just the special ed students, and even the special ed students with significant support needs."

Sessions' appointment has been condemned by the Autistic Self Advocacy Network, which called the Department of Justice's work as "vital to the disability community" but called Sessions "a staunch opponent of civil liberties."

"We have grave concerns that under Sessions, the Department of Justice would not protect the rights of disabled people and other marginalized populations," ASAN wrote.

Their concern grows from his past characterization of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), passed in 1975 to ensure children with disabilities received the education they deserved as much as other students.  In his statements, Sessions said the laws that protect and ensure education to special education students "may be the single most irritating problem for teachers throughout America today" and "very sincerely" suggested that accommodations for students with disabilities are "a big factor in accelerating the decline in civility and discipline in classrooms all over America."

Sessions has already shown difficulty carrying out his legal duties to protect students with special needs while serving as Alabama's attorney general from 1994 to 1996, when he "used the power of his office to fight to preserve Alabama's long history of separate and unequal education," as Thomas J. Sugrue argues in an op-ed in The New York Times.  Despite the order of Alabama Circuit Court Judge Eugene W. Reese that the state fix the inequitable funding across the state's public schools, which had been preventing the poorest districts from providing "even basic services to students in need," Sessions spent his tenure fighting and attempting to discredit Reese.

It was four years into his first term as a U.S. senator that Sessions said on the floor, "It is clear that IDEA '97 not only undermines the educational process, it also undermines the authority of educators."

Yet his statements make it clear how little he understands IDEA, FAPE, special education, and the needs of students with disabilities.  In fact, when Sessions first describes special education students, he refers only to those with "a hearing loss, or a sight loss, or if they have difficulty moving around, in a wheelchair, or whatever."  It's unclear what "whatever" might refer to, but given that his examples are all outwardly identifiable physical disabilities, Sessions appears not to recognize that disabilities also include the vast number of less outwardly visible ones, such as autism and other developmental disabilities, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, dyslexia, mood disorders, cognitive disabilities, personality disorders, dysgraphia, sensory processing disorder and other "invisible" disabilities.

Sessions then identifies the biggest problem with IDEA as an obstacle to effective "discipline" in school.  "We are telling special children with physical disabilities, or disabilities as defined by the federal law, that they don't have to adhere to the same standards other children do," Sessions said.  "Right in the classroom, we create, by federal law, two separate standards for American citizens."

But his statements completely neglect what the purpose of special education is: to accommodate the needs of children with different abilities precisely because they cannot, developmentally or physically or cognitively, adhere to the standards set for other students.

"I can understand where he is coming from, but as a teacher of those students who get those different standards, most of my students are not capable of working on the regular standards, so we have alternate standards for children to learn," explained Melissa Patterson, a special education teacher in Milwaukee who has been working in special education since 1997.  "Some of those standards are behavior management practices, so yes, a student who knows better who slaps somebody will get suspended while a child who doesn't know better who slaps someone will get a chance to correct the behavior.  But if it continues, they get the same consequences."

Many of Patterson's children operate at the cognitive level of a 2-year-old despite being in fourth and fifth grade, she said.

"Two-year-olds don't know you don't slap someone or take away a toy, so there's a little bit of leniency," she said.  "Once they've learned it and you know they've learned it and they know better, that leniency is gone."

Rather than "undermining" the authority of educators, Patterson said IDEA leveled the playing field for students with special needs, ensuring that they receive just as much education from art, music, gym and other specialist teachers as regular education students.

"I think he needs to go sit in an actual special ed classroom and see how it works and see the good that is happening instead of what he thinks is happening because he clearly doesn't know a whole lot of anything," Patterson said.  "He needs to understand that regardless of disability, these kids are kids, and they're in school to learn.  We need to help them do that, and it's his job to enforce that that is done."

Toward the end of his statements, Sessions says he is "sorry that I'm old-fashioned and believe we should be teaching all students to be responsible for their behavior."  But his complaints actually are old-fashioned given the progress that has occurred in public education, suggested Carl Hendricksen, a 35-year veteran of special education teaching in Illinois.  Hendricksen retired from teaching special education in 2013 but the high school vocational classes he now teaches in Peoria, Illinois, still include some special education students.

"We've moved on from some of the expectations toward SPED students and the idea that if a student was acting out emotionally or physically, we should get them out of the building," Hendricksen said.  "Best practices teach the teachers and administrators that being fair is being consistent, but being consistent is not always fair.  Everybody behaves differently and functions differently, so the same punishment doesn't always fit the same crime for different people."

Hendricksen said one revelation for him during his teaching career involved thinking about what kind of treatment he would want his own children to receive.

"Students in special ed will be living, breathing citizens in this world.  How do you want to treat them?"  Hendricksen said.  "How would you want someone to treat your child?  Do I really want my kids treated like I'm treating these kids?"

Yet Sessions implied that he wanted to see more "punishments" and discipline for special education students who act out behaviorally, which is unlikely to be in the child's best interests.

"The solution would be understanding why those students have difficulties, and creating trainings based on that understanding, rather than suppression or 'extinction' or bribing, all of which ignore the reasons those students are extremely frustrated," Des Roches Rosa explained.  "Most often the students are having a hard time communicating what is wrong with them, due to communication challenges, processing needs or delays, illness or a medical condition, sensory sensitivities, or a combination of all the above."

Sessions also complained about the Individualized Education Program, or IEPs, that outline specific goals and accommodations for each student with special needs.  He cited a teacher's letter that IEPs have "become almost contracts with the parents, and schools have to obey them to the letter of the law" or else risk lawsuits.

But they are intended to be a contract, with input from not only the student's parent but also a general education teacher, an administrator, the student's special education teacher and any other specialists the student interacts with, Patterson said.

"What the problem is with that, I have no idea.  It's saying this is what we need to do to give your child what they need to be able to succeed in school," Patterson said.  "Can you be sued if you're not giving the kid what they need?  Yes.  Should you be sued?  Absolutely.  It's the school's job to educate the kids.  If they're not educating them, what are they doing and what are my taxes paying for?"

Des Roches Rosa agreed, pointing out that lawsuits over IEPs occur not because the plans are legally binding themselves but because "parents of kids with disabilities too often have to end up suing school districts in order to get the services that are their legal right under IDEA and FAPE."

A major reason for this, Des Roches Rosa said, is inadequate federal funding to meet students' needs, something Sessions himself noted in his remarks: "We agreed to pay 40% of the cost.  We have never paid more than 15% of the cost.  It has been below 10% in most years."

Patterson agreed that schools lack the funding they need to hire enough staff and to provide the different kinds of evidence-based training and strategies teachers need for effective classroom management.

"We say we're doing all these professional development opportunities, but it’s the same stuff we've been spoon-fed for 15 years that means absolutely nothing at all," she said.  "On both sides, we need not more PD but better quality PD and things that are going to work."

The lack of funding harms not only students but also special education teachers, such as the one in Loveland, Colorado, who filed a lawsuit against the district that let her go after she filed a 20-page police report on various injuries she received from students while on the job.  Sessions refers to similar concerns in his statements but blames these problems on the students—even though the new age of ubiquitous cameras has revealed that special education students risk mistreatment by staff as well.

Just last month, a teacher in Mississippi was caught on video pinning a student with special needs to the floor and then dragging the student across the gym floor by the student's hair.  In another video, she strikes the student on the head with a thermos.

Other videos elsewhere shows an officer beating a special education student in the hall, a teacher in Georgia kneeing a 4-year-old special needs child to the floor and a teacher in Brentwood, New York, physically assaulting a special education student by shoving him, then placing him in a headlock and dragging him out of the hallway.

An investigation at The Seattle Times found 5,000 restraint and seclusion incidents at 10 school districts, "but many of the incidents, at least as they were reported, did not appear to justify the need for restraints or isolation."

Sessions says he believes in public education, but he appears not to believe in "free appropriate public education" for all students based on the remarks he made—even though he would be responsible for enforcing FAPE as U.S. Attorney General.

"Anytime anyone targets special education students as having 'discipline' problems, that is a red flag for me," Des Roches Rosa said.  "If the school is sending home the message to parents that the kids are bad rather than in need of understanding and support, those students are going to spend their entire lives—in the class, and at home—in a state of constant trauma and stress.  That terrifies me."