Check out this interesting piece in Forbes magazine by global education contributor, Jordan Shapiro, titled "How Some Of The Poorest Girls In The World Get Exactly The Education They Need."
Generally salient, the article is about the ways in which NGO Camfed International supports secondary school students (especially girls) to complete their studies, gain life skills, and obtain a sense of self-worth and respect, using the teachings of former Camfed beneficiaries to edify the current generation.
Of course, I can't buy into all of it however, having lived and worked in Tanzania for just under nine years now (?!?!), so when he talks about secondary school education being strictly English-language-driven, a little scoff might escape me. Or when he assumes that local communities want to do what's best for their kids and are not "just out to get money," I may snicker. And at the idea that anything in Tanzania is "an intricate and sophisticated approach to solving major systemic problems," I can't help but just laugh aloud.
Still, it's nice to know that nchi yetu (our country) is well-regarded in the eyes of the international education world and that what all of us development people are trying to do is making some bit of difference in the grand scheme of things.
Mr. Shapiro's takeaway is actually pretty fair: it is possible for the tenets of Ujamaa to work in tandem with a modern-day system of governance. Whether they actually do or not is a whole 'nother story. Karibu tena Tanzania, Mr. Shapiro!
Original content back at ya next week!!
####
"To care for yourself, you need first to care for others — so that
you feel valued," one teenage girl reads from a black-and-white speckled
composition book.
She's standing at the front of a classroom in Tanzania, presenting
from her notes. Just moments ago, she was huddled in one of many small
groups, discussing answers to the prompt: what does it take to care for
yourself, to feel competent, to have self-esteem?
"What about accepting your strengths and accepting your weaknesses?" Another student interrupts her.
"And having the confidence to speak out," the first one jabs back playfully. The room erupts in laughter.
Unlike some of the other girls in the class, the girl in front of the
blackboard is not wearing a white cotton hijab. She's dressed in a long
orange skirt and a blue sweater. Just thinking about her sweater makes
the back of my neck itch. Tanzania is hot; really hot. I'm dripping with
perspiration — uncomfortable even wearing the thinnest linen shirt I
own. How does she bear the heat? How can any of these kids concentrate
on their studies while packed so tightly into this humid school room? With two or three kids sharing each seat, their shoulders rub up against
one another.
I notice that the dull, two-toned paint on the dirty walls is chipped
and that cracks in the plaster travel from the ceiling all the way down
to the floor. And even from inside the building, I'm conscious of the
hot sun glaring down on the rusty corrugated aluminum roof overhead. The
school reeks of sweat and it feels like an oven. But it's also an
architectural reminder of former president Julius Nyerere's Ujamaa socialism.
Nyerere was the first leader of the United Tanzanian Republic from
1960 (when it was still Tanganyika) to 1985. Ujamaa means "extended
family" or "brotherhood" — it was the word Nyerere used to describe his
vision of economic and social development. "Every citizen is an integral
part of the Nation and has a right to take an equal part in Government
at the local, regional and national level," he wrote in his Arusha
Declaration. His writing was succinct and inspiring, but ultimately,
Ujamaa policies did little to prevent devastating economic decline. Today, Tanzania's hunger level is rated "serious" by the Global Hunger
Index, with an estimated 32.1% of the population undernourished.
Nyerere wrote a treatise in 1967 entitled Education for Self-Reliance, in
which he called for free compulsory public schooling that would
contradict colonial "attitudes of inequality, intellectual arrogance, and
intense individualism." He thought Tanzania's education should focus on
agriculture and productivity. His influence is obvious when I'm
standing outside the classrooms. The simple rectangular school buildings
are built from concrete and arranged symmetrically around a
well-maintained courtyard. Late in the afternoon, I spot the students
singing together while they tend to the grounds, trimming the grass and
pruning the shrubs. Their end-of-day contributions would likely please
the former president if he were still alive. He envisioned egalitarian "school farms," where "students will relate work to comfort. They will
learn the meaning of living together and working together for the good
of all."
Inside the classroom, things get a bit more confusing. In my notes, I
keep scribbling the buzzwords of post-industrial capitalism — scalable,
entrepreneurship, identity, self-worth — right beside Ujamaa words like
community, care, work and support. I'm sitting in the back of the room
beside Lucy Lake, CEO of Camfed (Campaign for Female Education)— an organization that works with local community leaders and families
in sub-Saharan Africa to create networks which provide support to keep
girls in school. Since 1993, Camfed and its community partners have
directly supported 1,603,674 students in Zimbabwe, Zambia, Ghana,
Tanzania, and Malawi. And they estimate that nearly four million have
benefited from the "improved learning environment" that their work
provides.
The class that I'm sitting in is a perfect example of these "improved
learning environments." Shani, a short 27-year-old woman in yellow
flip-flops, paces back and forth. She's teaching a specially-designed
life-skills and well-being curriculum. When she was a girl, one of seven
children, she was only able to afford secondary school thanks to the
help of the local district council. In addition to personal expenses
like proper uniforms and shoes, secondary schools in Tanzania required
school fees — a practice that was only recently abolished. In 2009,
Shani joined CAMA, the Camfed association — a network of young, educated
women from rural communities which has 55,358 members across sub-Saharan
Africa. Then, in 2013, she joined Camfed's award-winning Learner Guide program,
an initiative which brings CAMA members back to their local schools in
order "to support marginalized children in their studies, help them
succeed, and create a better world for themselves and their
communities." She's energetic and exuberant as she leads the students
through exercises about the previous night's reading.
Each student has a book, entitled My Better World, opened in
front of them. It's written in Swahili, but I'm reading along in an
English language version of the text: "This book could help you make
your life a better life…this book could help you recognize, understand,
and overcome your day-to-day challenges…this book could help you become a
role model in your community." I'm amazed at the students' engagement,
their playful excitement, the way they seem to be performing for each
other (and for me and the other guests in the back of the room). There's
a familiar goofiness to their humor which I recognize as the same
harmless, age-appropriate, boundary-pushing that one sees among
middle-schoolers, tweens and teens all around the world.
"Accept yourself for who you are!" One of the students says in
Swahili, "Many people want to be rich, but if you don't accept that you
are poor, you will want to steal." I'm touched by their self-reflections
and I feel my lips often curling into that same half-smile, half-pout
hybrid expression that my psychotherapist always made whenever I
revealed vulnerabilities.
I ask a few students about the My Better World book after
class, and their responses all resonate with the predominant secular
conception of the 21st century self: personally unique, empowered,
autonomous, self-aware. In fact, they sound just like adults in the USA
when they read a self-help book for the first time. They're overly
enthusiastic converts, celebrating their new found wisdom, insisting
that the same curriculum should be available even to younger primary
school students. I look around just to make sure I'm not really on some
vegan pseudo-ashram in Southern California.
Soon my cynicism dissolves. "Basic human needs are not just food and
shelter," four girls tell me, "but also love and health." I nod in
agreement, convinced that some schools in the USA, Europe, and the UK
should use this My Better World book. After all, back home I'm
increasingly concerned that nobody's talking about the socio-economic 'soft-skills gap.' Folks rarely acknowledge that school-day
opportunities for identity exploration, or for students to consider
their own personal well-being, are distributed so inequitably. In the
USA, for example, the poor get drilled on grit, perseverance, and
eye-contact, while the wealthy get creativity, purpose, and empathy.
Here, thanks to Camfed, the poor get purpose, hope, belonging, respect. I tell Lucy Lake how impressed I am with My Better World
and she explains that although it was developed in partnership with
Pearson, creating it was really a process of aggregating local
expertise. This curriculum is apparently specific to sub-Saharan
Africa — written in collaboration with members of Camfed's regional
teams, most of whom are CAMA members themselves.
Still, if you ask me, the My Better World content seems
pretty universal; it features precisely the sort of focus on autonomy,
voice and empowerment that all tweens and teens will need to thrive in a
secular, post-industrial global economy. Researchers have linked this
sort of identity exploration to "intense engagement, positive coping,
openness to change, flexible cognition and meaningful learning" (Kaplan, Sinai, and Flum 2014). And I'd argue that one's ability to flourish in any particular economic
epoch is, to a large degree, dependent on having a sense of self that's
framed within the predominant conception of personhood. In our times,
that means accepting the individual — as opposed to the household, the
tribe, or the Paleolithic band — as the primary socio-economic unit
(hence, the current popularity of both the serial entrepreneur and the
personality brand).
Miraculously, Camfed managed to persuade the Tanzanian government to
allow CAMA Learner Guides like Shani to facilitate this Swahili language
My Better World curriculum in 151 secondary schools. That's a
pretty significant achievement when you consider that these schools have
always been strictly English-language only. And it was necessary. After
all, it would have been disingenuous to ask kids to explore their own
identities in a foreign language. So Camfed worked with politicians and
community leaders to get permission to teach in Swahili.
While some Tanzanian officials may have been reluctant in the
beginning, I suspect they've been convinced by now. Student performance
has increased by unprecedented amounts (effect sizes of 0.5 in English
and 1.0 in Math) at schools that include the Learner Guide program. Retention of marginalized girls has also improved: they are 38% less
likely to drop out than girls at comparable schools. What's more, 84% of
head-teachers said the sessions helped students feel more confident
about school. 96% of students agreed; they said the My Better World sessions "made them feel more positive about the future." 97% said it helped
them shape their goals. And 95% of the students said that the CAMA
Learner Guides were "role models."
No wonder. The CAMA Learner Guides are not teachers, but rather local
community members, local stakeholders — many of whom now serve at the
very same schools they once attended. "I'm a link between the school and
the community," Shani explains. Camfed has trained 3,903 young women
like her working as Learner Guides in 1,009 schools across Ghana,
Tanzania and Zimbabwe. They've reached 121,212 secondary school children
over the past year. In exchange for their commitment, Learner Guides
become eligible for interest-free micro loans through Kiva.org. Most of
them use the funds to start small businesses.
Julius Nyerere would probably be appalled. He certainly did not
envision an educational trajectory where self-empowerment leads to
individual entrepreneurship. But that's precisely what seems to be
working. I visited a few of the CAMA small businesses nearby: some
beauty salons, some dress shops. And at each one, I saw proud
women — often joined by proud husbands — excited to show off their
success. One woman showed me her handwritten bookkeeping system, and
explained that she couldn't do any of this without a good math
education.
I smiled and thought, yes, this is precisely what Julia Gillard,
Former Prime Minister of Australia and current chairwoman at the Global
Partnership for Education, meant when she spoke to me about "the transformative potential of education" last year. A few months
after our conversation, Gillard became Camfed's patron and said to a
group of CAMA Learner Guides in South Africa, "If you can deal with
poverty, then the girls, with their inherent strengths, will seize the
opportunities given to them. If you can get the right resources to the
right girls at the right time, then you will enable them — because they
are strong, and they're smart — to change their lives."
Members of the local district council, as well as all the headmasters
I met, agree. They've seen the impact that CAMA Learner Guides and the My Better World curriculum
has had on the secondary school kids. Most of them told me they hope
Camfed will develop a similar program that brings self-awareness and
empowerment to primary-school students too. And almost unanimously, they
cited the reduced drop-out rate, explaining that they can usually
attribute almost all attrition to just three causes: financial
insecurity, family instability, and teen pregnancy. Financial capital
only addresses the first. It takes local buy-in to address the second. And they insist that the best way to address teen pregnancy is through
precisely this kind of education.
To drive the point home, Jeanne Ndyetabura, a retired civil servant
who used to work in the department responsible for vulnerable children,
tells me the story of a local girl. At the time of her first
menstruation, the girl had no idea what was going on. Nobody had taught
her about her body. All she knew was that she was bleeding from the
inside. She was certain that this meant she was dying. So she ran away
from the school; she ran to die at home. She didn't tell anyone, not her
friends, not her classmates, not her teachers. Instead, she cried and
walked — terrified, worried. But along the way she met a boy. "Why are
you crying?" the boy asked. The girl explained and the boy laughed. "You
have nothing to worry about," he told her, "go home, clean up, sleep. Then come back in 7 days and I'll give you the medicine so this doesn't
happen again." She did as she was told and this is how she got pregnant.
Jeanne Ndyetabura insists that through education, girls
learn more self-respect, they understand their own bodies, they take
care of themselves. But I'm wary that this perspective inadvertently
places all the responsibility on the girls. I think about the
surrounding society's accountability. I'm certain that the solution is
not just an education that teaches girls how to be on their guard
against the supposed natural spirit of boys. Instead, complex problems
require multi-faceted approaches. And while I've seen enough data about
girls' education in the developing world to recognize the accuracy of
Camfed's slogan: "When you educate a girl, everything changes," I also
know that the simplicity of the phrase doesn't do justice to the
organization's intricate approach. It doesn't acknowledge the degree to
which their work depends on a local community's "knowledge capital,
social capital, and institutional capital."
Those are the terms that Camfed's founder, Ann Cotton, used when I first met her after she won the 2014 WISE Prize. Knowledge Capital, she explained, "resides in the community itself," they will always know more about what
they need than any outsider. Social Capital describes existing
community support systems that need to be mobilized and strengthened
rather than replaced. And Institutional Capital refers to pre-existing
institutions, like chiefs, schools, churches, and mosques which already
have a strong foothold within the community. "You need to honor and
dignify what already exists," Cotton explained.
Stuck in Dar es Salaam's abysmal traffic on the way to Julius Nyerere
International Airport, Lucy Lake confirms that the same attitude even
permeates Camfed's outlook on financial capital. "We approach from the
assumption that communities want to do what's best for their children
and will allocate the funds accordingly," she explains, "not from the
assumption that people are just out to get the money."
Most of my readers live in a world where political battles often rage
around tiny semantic distinctions between words like "welfare" and "entitlement," so I expect that people will dismiss Lucy Lake's
perspective as naïve and idealistic. But what I saw in Tanzania was an
intricate and sophisticated approach to solving major systemic problems. And I'm not the only one who thinks so. In a recent Brooking's Institute report on scaling-up solutions for education, Jenny Perlman Robinson and
Rebecca Winthrop explain that Camfed "challenges the common perception
that community participation and efficient, accountable management are
incompatible in the transition from small, single-community initiatives
to large-scale, multi-community or multi-country programs."
I was still sweating in the airport restaurant. Lucy Lake and I were
eating cashews and drinking fruit juice while discussing other examples
of education programs for the developing world. We shared a mutual
appreciation for some and a wariness about top-down, drop-in, and
secular, missionary-like approaches. I heard them call my flight number
over the loudspeaker and I gathered my belongings to head to the gate. In place of goodbye, Lucy Lake paused and spoke as if she wanted to
punctuate all of the conversations the two of us had all week. She said, "the distance to school is not only about how far you have to walk."
A few days after I arrived home, I started hearing all those familiar
debates about whether to blame poor student performance on bad schools
with lazy teachers, or on toxic home environments with un-engaged
caretakers. Frankly, that discussion seems downright silly now. I've
seen first-hand that it is possible to blend Ujamaa socialist values
with post-industrial individual entrepreneurship — to create functional
community networks, which honor local expertise and mobilize all the
stakeholders together, so that they can care for individual students'
well-being, even in the face of extreme poverty.
